计算机论⽂投tmc期刊,IEEETMC意见是
ReviseandResubmitasNew希。。。
今天早上收到编辑的审稿意见:Revise and Resubmit as New。今年9⽉投的稿,这轮审稿2个⽉的时间,其中四个审稿⼈⼀个是minor revision,两个是Major Revision,唯独⼀位给的是reject,感觉编辑回复并没有正⾯评价,⼼⾥好慌:
We now have reviews of your above referenced submission to IEEE Transactions on Mobile Computing. Copies of the review comments are enclosed.
Unfortunately, based on these reviews, we are not able to recommend this submission for publication.
You may resubmit your paper, but it will be treated as a NEW submission and given a new log number. If you choose to resubmit your paper please include this original log number in your cover letter when submitting. Please also be sure to include a separate, supplementary file with the summary of the changes you have made in response to the AE and reviewers. We will link your two submissions' records. The new manuscript will then undergo a new review process.
副编的评论,基本都是再说问题:
While the reviewers found the topic of this work to be timely, there were some fundamental
Overall, the authors have raised serious concerns on the contribution of this work and, hence, this paper cannot be accepted in TMC in its current form.
We hope that you will find the comments from the reviewers to be useful in your future work. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.
除了⼩修那位审稿⼈,其他⼏位审稿⼈都给了不少极有⽤的意见。
这样的话,重投机会还⼤吗?
submitting重投的话,会重新换审稿⼈吗?另外周期⼤概多久
谢谢⼤家了

版权声明:本站内容均来自互联网,仅供演示用,请勿用于商业和其他非法用途。如果侵犯了您的权益请与我们联系QQ:729038198,我们将在24小时内删除。